For the week of Thanksgiving, we're featuring reruns as our leftovers -
literary characters as seen on TV who have been previously featured in this
showcase.
And for Thanksgiving Day, we have over-stuffed the gallery with three
versions of Dame Agatha Christie's Belgian sleuth, Hercule Poirot.
When he was featured early in the year, we used the Poirot from the
Cineverse Borderlands. And we still have not given this "tribute" to the
Hercule Poirot of Earth Prime-Time, as played by David Suchet.
CREATED BY:
Dame Agatha Christie
AS PORTRAYED BY:
Alfred Molina
AS SEEN IN:
"Murder On The Orient Express"
TV STATUS:
Recastaway
TV DIMENSION:
Evil Toobworld
Liberties with the original story can be expected in any TV production.
For the official Earth Prime-Time adaptation of this, the best known of Poirot's
cases, a major revision was given to the televersion of Dr. Constantine. But
that not only worked, in my opinion it was an improvement over the original
story. However, this TV movie eliminated too many characters and by doing so
removed the important reason for such a large cast. And thus, it is EVIL!
AS PORTRAYED BY:
Martin Gabel
AS SEEN IN:
'G.E. True Theater'
"Hercule Poirot"
TV STATUS:
Recastaway (Original)
TV DIMENSION:
Prequel Toobworld
Gabel's performance as Poirot was the first appearance for the character
and this episode of the anthology series served as a pilot for a proposed TV
show. Normally the rule in Toobworld is the first portrayal of any character is
the official televersion for Earth Prime-Time. But a one-shot version has to be
put aside in favor of a recastaway who logs more screen time with an actual
series, and such is the case here. By the end of next year, David Suchet will
have been seen in adaptations of every single story by Christie about Poirot.
He will forever stand as the benchmark for the role. Gabel's performance then
has to be relegated to the world of prequels (no good name for that world yet)
in which we also find Art Carney's version of Horace Ford and Stuart Margolin as
Rabbi David Small.
(I'd also like to think his TV dimension might be that of "Over There" as
seen in 'Fringe', if only for the fact that Martin Gabel's grandson Seth Gabel
played FBI/Fringe Division Agent Lincoln Lee in that world.)
I need to get to the Paley Center one of these days and see if they have Gabel's performance in the archives......
PORTRAYED BY:
Sir Ian Holm
AS SEEN IN:
"Murder By The Book"
TV STATUS:
Dream Figure
TV DIMENSION:
Earth Prime-Time Dream
Toobworld Central makes allowances for recasting due to aging. So Dame
Peggy Ashcroft is Dame Agatha Christie for Earth Prime-Time as a woman near the
end of her life, while Fenella Woolgar is the younger Agatha Christie as seen in
the 'Doctor Who' episode "The Unicorn And The Wasp". Holm's Poirot is merely
the manifestation of Christie's sleuth in a dream she had while working out the
details for the last book to be written about Poirot, "Curtain".
Happy Thanksgiving, everyone. As one of our Poirots (at least!) would never say:
"Gabel Gabel Gabel!"
BCnU!